The future of transportation fuels will be shaped by a mix of innovation, government policies, and what consumers want. Photo by Engin Akyurt/Pexels

Gasoline, diesel, bunker fuel, and jet fuel. Four liquid hydrocarbons that have been powering transportation for the last 100-plus years.

Gas stations, truck stops, ports, and airport fuel terminals have been built up over the last century to make transportation easy and reliable.

These conventional fuels release Greenhouse Gases (GHG) when they are used, and governments all over the world are working on plans to shift towards cleaner fuels in an effort to lower emissions and minimize the effects of climate change.

For passenger cars, it’s clear that electricity will be the cleaner fuel type, with most countries adopting electric vehicles (EVs), and in some cases, providing their citizens with incentives to make the switch.

While many articles have been written about EVs and the benefits that come along with them, they fail to look at the transportation system as a whole.

Trucks, cargo ships, and airplanes are modes of transportation that are used every day, but they don’t often get the spotlight like EVs do.

For governments to be effective in curbing transportation-related greenhouse emissions, they must consider all forms of transportation and cleaner fuel options for them as well.

43 percent of GHG emissions comes from these modes of transportation. Therefore, using electricity to reduce GHG emissions in light duty vehicles only accounts for part of the total transportation emissions equation.

The path to cleaner fuels for these transportation modes has its challenges.

According to Ed Emmett, Fellow in Energy and Transportation Policy at the Baker Institute Center for Energy Studies (CES);

  • "Airplanes cannot be realistically powered by electricity, at least not currently, and handle the same requisite freight and passenger loads"
  • "The long-haul trucking industry [...] pushed back against electrification as being impractical due to the size and weight of batteries, their limited range, and the cost of adoption"
  • "Shipowners have expressed reluctance to scrap existing bunker fueled ships for newer, more expensive ships, especially when other fueling options, e.g. biofuels and hydrocarbon derivatives-for fleets can be made available"

Finding low-cost, reliable, and environmentally sound fuels for the various segments of transportation is complex. As Emmett suggests in his latest article;

"Hovering over the transition to other fuels for almost every transportation mode is the question of dependability of supply. For the trucking industry, the truck stop industry must be able to adapt to new fuel requirements. For ocean shipping, ports must be able to meet the fuel needs of new ships. Airlines, air cargo carriers and airports need to be on the same page when it comes to aviation fuels. In other words, the adoption equation in transitions in transportation is not only a function of the availability and cost of the new technology but also a function of the cost of the full supply chain needed to support fuel production and delivery to the point of use. Going forward, the transportation industry is facing a dilemma: How are environmental concerns addressed while simultaneously maintaining operational efficiency and avoiding unnecessary upward cost shifts for moving goods and people? In answering that question, for the first time in history, modes of transportation may end up going in multiple different directions when it comes to the fuels each mode ultimately chooses."

This is why many forecasts predict that hydrocarbon demand will continue through 2050, despite ambitious aspirations of achieving net zero emissions by that year. The McKinsey "slow evolution" scenario has global liquid hydrocarbon demand in 2050 at 92mmb/d versus 103 mmb/d in 2023. With their "continued momentum" scenario, oil demand is 75 mmb/d. Proportionally, global oil demand related to GHG emissions from transportation would decline 11-27 percent. The global uptake of EVs is the primary driver of uncertainty around future oil demand. In all the McKinsey scenarios, the share of EVs in passenger cars sales is expected to be above 90 percent by 2050.

The Good News

Despite the relatively slow progress expected for reducing GHG emissions in the global transportation sector, there are solutions emerging that lower the carbon footprint tied to traditional petroleum-based fuels. Emmett highlights some of the methods under study, noting that "sustainable biofuels sourced from cooking oils, animal fats, and agriculture products, as well as hydrogen, methanol, ammonia, and various e-fuels are among the options being tested. Some ocean carriers are already ordering ships powered by liquified natural gas, bio-e-methanol, bio/e-methane, ammonia, and hydrogen. Airlines are already using sustainable aviation fuel as a supplement to basic aviation fuel. Railroads are testing hydrogen locomotives. The trucking industry is decarbonizing local delivery by using vehicles powered by electricity, compressed natural gas, and sustainable diesel. Long-haul trucking companies are considering sustainable diesel as a drop-in fuel for existing equipment, and fuel suppliers are researching new engines fueled by hydrogen and other alternative fuels."

Most of these options will require a combination of increased government incentives, along with advancements in technology and cost reductions.

McKinsey's "sustainable transformation" scenario, which considers potential shifts in government regulations as well as advancements in technology and cost, suggests there is moderate growth in alternative fuels alongside growth in EVs. Mckinsey projects;

  • EV demand could grow to over 90 percent of total passenger car sales by 2050
  • EVs to make up around 80 percent of commercial truck sales by 2050
  • In aviation, low carbon fuels such as biofuels, synfuels, hydrogen and electricity are projected to grow to 49 percent by 2050.

According to McKinsey, the combination of these alternatives along with demand changes in power and chemicals could reduce global oil demand to 60 mmb/d in 2050. The shift to cleaner fuels, for modes of transportation other than EVs, is underway but the progress and adoption will take decades to achieve according to McKinsey’s forecasts.

Looking more closely at EVs, the story may not be as dire globally as it seems to be in the West. While the U.S. appears to be losing momentum on electric vehicle adoption, China is roaring ahead. New electric car registrations in China reached 8.1 million in 2023, increasing by 35 percent relative to 2022. McKinsey’s forecasts have underestimated global EV sales in the past, with China surpassing their estimates, while the U.S. lags behind. It’s clear that China is the winner in EV adoption; could they also lead the way to adopt cleaner fuels for other modes of transport? That is something governments and the transportation industry will be watching in the years ahead.

Conclusion

While we are not on a trajectory to meet the aspirations to reduce global GHG emissions in the transportation sector, there are emerging solutions that could be adopted should governments around the world decide to put in place the incentives to get there. Moving forward, the future of transportation fuels will be shaped by a mix of innovation, government policies, and what consumers want. The focus will be on ensuring that the transportation sector remains reliable, secure, and economically robust, while also reducing GHG emissions. But, decarbonizing the transportation sector is much more than just EV's – it's a broader effort that will require continued global progress in each of the multiple transportation segments.

------------

Scott Nyquist is a senior advisor at McKinsey & Company and vice chairman, Houston Energy Transition Initiative of the Greater Houston Partnership. The views expressed herein are Nyquist's own and not those of McKinsey & Company or of the Greater Houston Partnership. This article originally ran on LinkedIn on October 9, 2024.

The layoffs could affect about 14,000 of the 140,473 workers employed by the Austin, Texas, company at the end of last year. Photo courtesy of Tesla

Tesla plans to lay off 10 percent of workforce after dismal quarterly sales

making cuts

After reporting dismal first-quarter sales, Tesla is planning to lay off about a tenth of its workforce as it tries to cut costs, multiple media outlets reported Monday.

CEO Elon Musk detailed the plans in a memo sent to employees. The layoffs could affect about 14,000 of the 140,473 workers employed by the Austin, Texas, company at the end of last year.

Musk's memo said that as Tesla prepares for its next phase of growth, “it is extremely important to look at every aspect of the company for cost reductions and increasing productivity,” The New York Times and CNBC reported. News of the layoffs was first reported by electric vehicle website Electrek.

Also Monday, two key Tesla executives announced on the social media platform X that they are leaving the company. Andrew Baglino, senior vice president of powertrain and energy engineering, wrote that he had made the decision to leave after 18 years with the company.

Rohan Patel, senior global director of public policy and business development, also wrote on X that he was leaving Tesla, after eight years.

Baglino, who held several top engineering jobs at the company and was chief technology officer, wrote that the decision to leave was difficult. “I loved tackling nearly every problem we solved as a team and feel gratified to have contributed to the mission of accelerating the transition to sustainable energy,” he wrote.

He has no concrete plans beyond spending more time with family and his young children, but wrote that he has difficulty staying still for long.

Musk thanked Baglino in a reply. “Few have contributed as much as you,” he wrote.

Shares of Tesla fell 4.8 percent Monday afternoon, hours after news of the layoffs and departures broke. Shares of Tesla Inc. have lost about one-third of their value so far this year as sales of electric vehicles soften.

Tesla sales fell sharply last quarter as competition increased worldwide, electric vehicle sales growth slowed, and price cuts failed to draw more buyers. The company said it delivered 386,810 vehicles from January through March, nearly 9 percent below the 423,000 it sold in the same quarter of last year.

Since last year, Tesla has cut prices as much as $20,000 on some models as it faced increasing competition and slowing demand. The price cuts caused used electric vehicle values to drop and clipped Tesla's profit margins.

The company has said it will reveal an autonomous robotaxi at an event in August.

Ad Placement 300x100
Ad Placement 300x600

CultureMap Emails are Awesome

Houston geothermal company lands $3M in DOE funding for superhot energy tech

hot new funding

A Houston-based company has been selected to receive a portion of $30 million in funding through the Department of Energy's ARPA-E program's SUPERHOT geothermal initiative.

XGS Energy was named among eight companies, universities and labs to receive portions of the funding, which aims to more than triple the output of individual geothermal wells and help deliver 10 gigawatts to 20 gigawatts of geothermal power by 2040, according to a news release.

The SUPERHOT program, which stands for Stimulate Utilization of Plentiful Energy in Rocks through High-temperature Original Technologies, was first announced last year and aims to "develop novel technologies for well construction, enhance testing facilities, and optimize reservoir heat extraction for cost-effective super-hot geothermal production, with focus on scalable Enhanced Geothermal Systems (EGS) and Advanced Geothermal Systems (AGS)," according to its website.

XGS Energy, which recently relocated its headquarters from Palo Alto, California, to Houston, will receive $3 million through the program. The funding will go toward adapting and validating the company's proprietary thermally conductive cement and well design for use in superhot geothermal conditions. XGS says its closed-loop design is less vulnerable to the extreme heat and pressure of geothermal wells.

The funding comes shortly after XGS was named in September among three Houston companies to receive a portion of more than $45 million in funding from the DOE's Next-Generation Geothermal Field Tests and Geothermal Resource Characterization and Confirmation initiative. The projects were among 21 selected from around the country to receive a total of $99 million.

"Superhot resources offer a path to more efficient, reliable baseload power for America,” XGS’s Chief Technology Officer Axel-Pierre Bois said in a news release. “This ARPA-E project reflects our commitment to pushing the frontiers of geothermal energy, expanding domestic energy production and delivering around-the-clock power for our grids and critical infrastructure.”

Frisco-based Blade Energy Partners, which has an office in Houston, was also selected to receive funding through the SUPERHOT program. The company landed $6.3 million for its Enabling Robust SHR Well Design and Construction project, which will test and develop an integrated well design using advanced materials, like steel alloys, to withstand extreme superhot geothermal conditions and extend well integrity beyond 15 years.

The remaining organizations selected for SUPERHOT funding include:

  • Oak Ridge National Laboratory — $3 million
  • University of Southern California — $3 million
  • The University of Oklahoma — $3 million
  • Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory — $5.5 million
  • Pacific Northwest National Laboratory — $2.6 million
  • Los Alamos National Laboratory — $3.5 million

Read more about the projects here.

Houston alliance launches effort to establish Gulf Coast national energy lab

energy innovation

Houston energy stakeholders are setting plans in motion to advance a new national laboratory on the Gulf Coast focused on energy and industrial technologies.

The proposed U.S. Department of Energy national lab, known as the Gulf Coast National Laboratory (GCNL), would build on work launched by the Greater Houston Partnership's Houston Energy Transition Initiative (HETI), according to a news release. Founding academic members include Rice University and the University of Houston. Plans for the lab and the new Gulf Coast National Laboratory Alliance were announced at an event at the GHP's Partnership Tower on Nov. 12.

The GCNL's main goal would be bridging the gap between the research and development of promising energy technology and commercialization. It would aim to provide shared pilot facilities, integrated process-scale testing and public-private partnerships.

Focus areas would include:

  • Subsurface technologies
  • Produced water management
  • Process engineering and scale-up
  • Industrial process engineering and supply chains

"The United States has extraordinary research capabilities, but too many promising technologies struggle to cross the gap between proof-of-concept and commercial success," Jane Stricker, executive director of the GCNLA and former executive director of HETI, said in the release. "Our mission is to bring together the organizations and leaders needed to create a scale-up platform that enables technologies to move from innovation to industry faster, more cost-effectively, and at a scale that strengthens U.S. energy security, industrial productivity, and supply-chain resilience."

The new lab will also complement existing DOE labs, which "execute long-term government missions and develop unique scientific capabilities that often extend beyond the scope of academic and industrial institutions," according to the organization's website. There are currently 10 DOE national labs, including the likes of the Ames National Laboratory, the Argonne National Laboratory, the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory and others.

Organizers say the proposed GCNL would serve as "the nation's premier scale-up and deployment platform for energy and industrial technologies." They add that the Gulf Coast is primed for a lab due to the high concentration of energy and industrial infrastructure in the area.

According to the release, Texas produces approximately 43 percent of the nation’s crude oil and the Gulf Coast is home to nearly half of the country's refining capacity.

"By bringing together industry, academia, and government partners, we can reinforce the Gulf Coast's position as the nation's leading energy and industrial hub while advancing U.S. competitiveness and energy security," Steve Kean, president and CEO of the GHP, added in the release.

Organizers are calling on energy companies, academic institutions, investors and other groups to partner on the initiative. There are currently about 20 members of the alliance supporting the lab, ranging from energy giants to venture capital groups and Houston startups.

Current members include:

  • Artemis Energy Partners
  • Baker Hughes
  • Cemvita
  • Dow
  • Energy Transition Ventures
  • ExxonMobil
  • Flour
  • Greater Houston Partnership
  • Greentown Labs
  • HETI
  • LyondellBasell
  • Mitsubishi Heavy Industries
  • New Climate Ventures
  • Rice University
  • San Jacinto College
  • SCF Partners
  • SLB
  • Solidec
  • Syzygy Plasmonics
  • Texas Southern University
  • The University of Houston
  • Via Separations